American Pie of Millbury

I’m almost positive that the negative reviews on here are from competitors and those related to competitors, because my husband and I tried this place tonight and DANG! By FAR the best pizza in town. Pizza is big and delicious and not super greasy like other reviews stated. Hot, fully cooked and AMAZING. I can’t even describe the taste, idk if it’s the sauce or what but it’s like taking a bite out of nostalgia. It’s so good! My only gripe would be I wish the onion rings were shoe string - but the thicker ones are just as good! I also appreciate the side of Alfredo dipping sauce - you guys are great - we will DEFINITELY be back again. I hope everyone tries this joint, you won’t be disappointed!

I will give three stars because I understand that this location just recently opened so I will give them the benefit of the doubt.

The food is decent. Portions are extremely small. Ordered the zesty lime shrimp and avocado salad, $12 and some change for it and it looks like a side salad. Also ordered the firecracker chicken wrap, it is drenched with hot sauce.

The chicken, bacon, ranch white pizza is bomb.com though. I’d recommend that.

This is the only pizza I like in Millbury. Pizza Chef and A and D can’t compare. The other food I got to was amazing too. Buffalo wings and mozzarella. Pretty cheap to.

The pizza here is great! New York Style crust, this is not greek style at all, which is why there are bad reviews. I've also had some of the sandwiches, and they are superb, extremely flavorful.
The service could use work, but it is very obvious that is because they have only been open for 2 weeks. The staff are extremely friendly, but they do not have great systems in place yet. All the service problems will be solved once they have had a chance to iron out their procedures.