Stillwater Proper

Stopped in for a late lunch, and this place is a total gem. We each ordered a meal; she had the Stilly Cheesesteak, and I had the Pork Belly Sticky Rice Bowl. Both were decent sized portions, delicious, and seasoned well. The cocktail list was diverse and superb. The wine pour was generous.

Atmosphere is cool, with a metal bar top and copper accents, wood beams accenting industrial elements in the ceiling. Bar stools were comfortable and the service was top notch.

We will definitely be back.

Super satisfied with this restaurant!!! Maybe a little niche for picky eaters, and that’s the only reason we would give 4 stars. Otherwise we really enjoyed. We got the Proper Burger and Pirate Dog. Toga fries are amazing. Also the staff is super accommodating, friendly and personable!

Great food at Stillwater Proper. I had the Proper burger + fried egg and it was deliciously messy as a good burger should be. I ordered the regular fries as my side and while I'm not a huge french fry fan, they were really really good.

The restaurant makes great use of its unique space as it's longer than it is wide. The kitchen is tucked right behind the bar in plain view. But it was not loud or distracting at all. Only thing is that the volume of the place was very very loud. Of course we ate at peak dinner time on a Friday in Stillwater but I could barely hear my friends sitting next to me at our high top table for 4.

Definitely recommend and will eat here again. They had a small "pop up" menu that was featuring many Hawaiian inspired dishes. My friends ordered the Pork Belly bowl and said it was absolutely delicious.

Very reasonable prices as well! We thought they had missed something on our bill but everything was there.

From handcrafted burgers to sticky rice bowls, Stillwater Proper is an exceptional restaurant. The perfect choice for a date night or a mid-week lunch in historic downtown Stillwater. Delicious food and craft cocktails.

What a fabulous place and an absolute must stop! Even if you just want to pop in for a drink, definitely do! Our fabulous server recommended things that we probably never would’ve ordered, specifically the bologna sandwich… Everything was absolutely delightful!!