Sinatra's Pizza

This place has come a long way since it was Tina's pizza. They have great pizza and use good product on everything. The price is good and the staff is very friendly and accommodating. It a little open feeling in the dining area, but they make the best of it. It's definitely worth a try if you had a bad taste in the past.

Bob and I have been to just about every restaurant in Flemington and beyond! So when he said we were going to Sumatra’s on route 31, I thought oh good the pizzeria. We go there and we’re greeted by Giovanni who runs the place. I said to Bob oh it’s so damn bright in here. So we ordered appetizers bruschetta bread and garlic bread. The bruschetta bread was the very best I have had anywhere and that’s saying a lot. You may say so what so bruschetta bread was good. No it does matter and this was excellent and so was the fresh garlic bread. The chef shows he or she cares. Then came my chicken franchise and the chicken parm and ziti. Well let me tell you everything was excellent. So so good. I feel that at this point I qualified to critique, and this is not a pizzeria, ita a fine Italian food restaurant. Loved it and if you don’t go you are truly missing out. Giovanni said he would tone down the lighting lol. Other than that bon apetit! !!!

Soli and Bobby
2/8/24.

This place is phenomenal! I don't know how anyone could have anything bad to say about this place.
The food was fantastic, flavorful and abundantly portioned.
The service was top notch and I felt like I was eating in someone's dining room, that's how attentive they were.
If you haven't tried this place, GO NOW!
Whether you just want a quick slice to go or a full meal, this is where you want to go for a delicious bite to eat!

Brought my family in for dinner. Super impressed by the food. We had pizza that was so good , we ordered a second pie. Pasta dishes were a good portion size, and loaded with flavor. We will be going back as often as we can. My new go to spot in the area.

First time here. I thought the pizza was very good! Got a veggie pizza to go. It was $22 but I had a coupon so not bad. The veggies were very good and the pizza was crunchy. Looking forward to trying something else!