Nassau Street Seafood & Produce Co.

Delicious fish sandwich melts in your mouth. Always fresh and always tasty. You have many options to choose from.

A true Princeton gem. Very helpful nice guys, been going there for lunch for years. The fish selection and quality is amazing, you'd think you were on the coast or something. I typically get lunch here, they have daily specials in the $9-14 dollar range, fish sandwiches or such with fries, along with a collection of salads, soups, etc. Fridays are excellent lobster roll specials (and weekends). They will also quickly grill fish you buy, which is a great way to make a heart-healthy dinner very easily.

Excellent seafood, I recommend this place to everyone. Best lobster roll ever.

This place is exceptional. There's a reason they have almost a perfect rating here. The selection of seafood is amazing, and everything is superb quality and always fresh. Moreover, the guys who work here really know their fish. You can ask them about any piece of fish in the place, they'll tell you what it's like, where it's from, and even the best way to cook it. Some days I just walk in and say "what's good today?" and they'll recommend 4 or 5 things that stand out. But honestly, you could walk in here and blindly point at something behind the counter and you know it's gonna be great. They also supply the fish for Blue Point Grill next door, same owners I believe, so if you've been there (it's amazing too) that's the level of quality fish you can expect here. Absolute top shelf stuff.