Jeppy's Pizzeria

Definitely worth the visit. The inside dining is rather small but the food is great.

AWESOME food and A++ Service.

The salads with olives are great! The seafood dishes are divine!

The best tomato pie in hamilton. Small shop big flavor. Not much room to sit down, but does offer carry out and delivery. Jeppy and Dave assure all their customers that the quality of their food is to be matched.

The seating area inside is very small so you can tell Jeppy's is primarily designed more to grab and go.
Parking lot around back can't hold a lot of cars so you're probably better off parking on the street nearby.
During rush hours it's usually hard to get someone on a phone to place an order, but when you are able to place an order they're ready in a timely manner.
The staff we interacted with was very polite and nice to interact with.
We ordered an Italian hoagie, a cheese steak and a pizza and they were all good. Rolls have the right amount of bite and none of the sandwiches felt like it was primarily bread. Pizza was a nice size and easy to eat, it felt a little on the thin side but there were no doughy spots throughout.
Jeppy's is definitely our new go-to food spot and we can't wait to try more. They also deliver, which I'm sure is a plus with the odd parking near the building.