Psychedelicatessen Sandwich Shop

Just popped in for the first time, the owner is super cool and friendly. The honey sponge sandwich was off the hook good as was the Scone.

MEATBALL MASTERY AND REUBEN REVELATION! Just ordered sandwiches for lunch. Meatball sub is perfectly constructed and executed. Meatball is a mix of ground meats, more white (pork/veal/chicken not beef) versus heavier darker beef. Perfectly executed. Very light. Very moist. Great sauce, good tomatoes (you know it when they use the good stuff). Good bread - just a little "spring" to it holds the whole thing together despite the potential for one big gooey mess (didn't happen as this was "good and gone" in no time). Bravo! Rueben well executed too. Slight smoke in the meat?!? Great rye bread. Good kraut. Grilled to perfection. Tangy Russian. A fine sandwich. These guys really know what they are doing. Prices a little high but worth every cent in my view. Great name for a great deli.

the BEST cold brew and hot coffee in all of Brooklyn hands down. & the nicest and warmest people! every cake, sweet treat & sandwich i’ve tried from this place has been 10000/10. never going anywhere else for coffee or tiramisu!!!

Really great sandwiches and the owner is super nice. Definitely have to come back and try everything on the menu!

Sandwiches galore - this place has it all! Hands down one of the best sandwiches in NYC (definitely the best in South Brooklyn). From chicken and prosciutto to veggies, there’s a sandwich for everyone. Fresh coffee and baked goods are also mind bogglingly delicious. Don’t sleep on Psychedelicatessen!!!