Jake's Steakhouse

My fiance and I went here for her birthday during a small snow storm. There was very few people at the restautant because of that reason, but regardless, we still received great service from the waiter and staff. The food was great as well. I had the shell steak and my fiance had a seafood pasta dish. For dessert, we shared a brownie sundae. All around, it was a good experience. Why is it 4 stars instead of 5... I wasn't a fan of the old style interior. And to be honest, as the food was great and service was great, there are other fantastic steak house restaurants around Long Island and I just can't put this place in that category. If I can give this place 4 and a half stars, I would, but it's very tough to say it's one of the top tier steak houses I've ever had. Overall, I do recommend this place and yes, I would come back.

Service was not the best. We went for restaurant week on a Friday night. We weren’t asked what we wanted to eat until half an hour after we were seated. We got our appetizers before bread, which we had to ask for twice. I could’ve made the Pasta primavera better at home. Steak was dry. Croquettes had bacon which wasn’t listed on the menu & I specifically do not eat bacon at all. It’s not that fancy and this is basically an older crowd hang out spot (at the bar). Apple crumble dessert was so good though!

Great staff, great service & tasty food. In my opinion the wine list is way over priced but you won't be disappointed. Everything my wife & had was delicious.. enjoy!!

In a word, amazing. Our go to steak house. Comfortable atmosphere. Delicious food. Enough to choose from even if you're not a steak lover. Good selection of after dinner coffees. Service is always good

The best kept secret steakhouse on Long Island! They own their butcher so the steaks are always great. I go with the 35 day dry aged prime rib eye. Best steak anywhere! Also get the oysters, charred broccoli, and cauliflower mash.