Fratelli's Italian Eatery

Ordered for delivery. Not impressed for my first time ordering. Ordered Chicken Marsala plater with Linguini, was delivered Chicken breast in some watery sauce under Spaghetti with some mushrooms and onions on top. Sorry, but that's not Chicken Marsala and not exactly what I ordered. All Dinner orders come with a pasta according to the menu. The other Dinner platter ordered did not even though I stated Linguini for that too. But I did like the bread. So a disappointment on my first try. I may try again... Pizza maybe.

Fast, reliably tasty and fresh local deli/pizza place
Great prices on family meal packages. Why bother cooking?!

Great Italian hero and very affordable pricing on the whole menu. Will definitely be going back !

Fratelli's is a deli that also happens to have a brick-oven pizzeria. Although they do not specialize in pizza, do not let that discourage you. The Sicilian slice of pizza I got was delicious. The crust they use is not bland, it actually tastes very good. The cheese and sauce were pretty great too.

On the other hand, the regular slice lacked the integrity of the Sicilian slice. It was VERY oily, to the point that some of the oil soaked through the crust. I used napkins to soak up the excess oil. As a result, the end of the slice did not hold up as it should, it was floppy. The crust of the regular pizza was also a bit thin for my liking, which is a shame because this pizzeria seems to use high-quality dough.

The garlic knots were DELICIOUS. They were flavorful throughout, and had an amazing texture.

It was $7.05 (with tax) for a regular slice, Sicilian slice, and 2 garlic knots, so this pizzeria is a bit on the pricey side. The actual restaurant is nice, but there were some flies around the food, especially near the garlic knots, which was concerning.

Overall, if you are near Stony Brook, Fratelli's is certainly worth trying. It is a good pizzeria, despite a few flaws.

Exactly what I needed for lunch! Very relaxing. Comfortable chairs and good prices. The gentleman behind the counter was very personable. Great all around!