18 Bay

If you are into tasting menus or unique little spots, this is sincerely one of the best Suffolk has to offer.

This is the perfect country restaurant-- beautiful fresh ingredients and inventive dishes, a sweet setting with lovely service. Not super fancy and very reasonable prices for what you get. In the warmer months nothing beats a table on the porch. Always a great evening but this is not your place if you're a picky eater because you don't have a lot of choice.

Great place, tasting menu was fantastic, and the service was top notch. We were greeted by Jimmy who runs the front of the house. Very welcoming atmosphere with a fine dining feel. We can’t wait to get back to shelter island

We thoroughly enjoyed our dining experience here. The food was fantastic as were the cocktails. The staff was accommodating, attentive and friendly. One of the best dining experiences we have had. Highly recommended.

Beautiful setting .... high level of service. Menu is a prefixe and changes weekly from locally sourced fish,vegetables...meat. expect to pay on average with drinks current pre fixe $75.00 per person.Worth the price for an amazing dining experience.