The Eccentric Bagel

I had Darryn’s newest creation today which was the Crème Brûlée bagel. It was absolutely delicious!

Absolutely loved the Eccentric Bagel! Decided to visit Shelter Island as a weekend getaway from western LI and did not expect to find one of my favorite bagel places of all time. Loved being in the area for the first time ever, and will definitely be back to the Eccentric Bagel, which has my highest recommendation. In addition to some amazing bagel sandwiches, the tuna salad was some of the best I've ever had. Loved seeing Cel-Ray so far east too!

This spot offers the best bagels I have ever tasted. They're a gourmet bagel, and they have a great variety of flavors to choose from (my fav is Rosemary & Salt & Everything). Whether you're a fan of a classic everything bagel or you're in the mood for something a bit more adventurous, the Eccentric Bagel got you covered.

But the bagels aren't the only standout item on the menu. The short rib pot pie is a delectable treat that I would highly recommend. The savory filling is perfectly complemented by the flaky pastry crust. It's the perfect comfort food for a chilly day.

In addition to the great food, the staff at the Eccentric Bagel is really friendly and welcoming. The charming owner is always around to strike up a conversation and make sure that everyone feels special. And the 80s decor adds a fun and quirky touch to the whole experience.

All in all, I would highly recommend the Eccentric Bagel! The food is delicious, the staff is wonderful, and the atmosphere is one of a kind.

The Eccentric Bagel isn't just place for breakfast, brunch or lunch --it's a total experience! We loved the colorful and clever decor, the super fun staff, and the home fries and eggs hit it out of the park! Darryn Weinstein has truly mastered the best bagel I've ever had and I'm a New Yorker! In addition to the basics, I tried as many of the incredible special flavors as I could. The Jalapeno-Cheddar and the Smoked Bacon left a lasting impression. And don't miss the Nitro Cold Brew...it's really frothy and yum! Absolutely worth a day trip!

I had the MOST AMAZING bagels ever at eccentric bagel. If you have not been here yet you MUST GO! The bagel sandwiches are unreal, I had the everything with cream cheese avocado and lox. The bagel was the perfect texture and consistency. I could also tell the ingredients were of the highest quality. Do not forget to try their nitro cold brew and dessert bagel!!!! Amazing experience and a must visit!