More Than Pizza Ithaca

Incredible new york pizza served quickly. Prices are good and there's plenty of seating. I love the BBQ chicken pizza!

Great food! It's a little pricey but good and nice portions. The TV was playing an old football game, and the commercials looked like they were early 90s or so. It was cute. Definitely recommend.

Ordered through Uber, and I live way out. I cannot tell you how good this is! I ordered the Gyro over rice. Inexpensive, plenty of food, and so very good.

There is definitely more than pizza. They have halal meat over rice. I had the chicken & gyro mix over rice in Large. It was great. Reminded me of the food trucks in NYC and Philly. Hard to say which I prefer. Maybe the mix is the way to go! The portion is decent. Enough left for me to have lunch the next day. High value for the price.
The owner is welcoming and friendly. Will definitely come again.

Context: My partner and I came in on a Friday at midnight. There were only college students as customers who were coming in. They were still putting out fresh pizza at this time.

Food: I ordered a mixed chicken and gyro dish over rice ($14). It came with a basic salad. The chicken was tender and moist, the gyro was flavorful, and the rice had the perfect texture. All were seasoned well and the sauces on top were a good balance of creamy and spicy. The salad was also crispy and cold (though pretty basic and not a lot of it). The portions were generous overall for the price, making this a good value.

Atmosphere: The store was brightly lit and had both booths and tables for eating at, though the store is small overall. They also have outdoor seating. They had salt, black pepper, red pepper, and Parmesan as condiments on the tables, as expected for a (more than) pizza place, but no halal food sauces readily available.

The only thing I could complain about was the flyer they had out that informed customers that they give a 4% discount for paying with cash instead of card (which we comfirmed with the cashier). We paid in cash and they just removed a few cents off our bill to give a round number, much less than 4%. 4% ends up being a small discount, but why even advertise this if you're not going to abide by it?

Conclusion: If their pizza is as good as their halal dish was, then I would probably come again just to try the pizza (they sell whole pies, but also sell $3-4 per large slice). I highly recommend their halal food!