Castello Pizza

This place is probably one of the best kept secrets in the North Campus area. In my opinion they make the best New York style pizza anywhere in Columbus. When you walk in you can see them making the dough by hand. The dough to sauce to cheese to topping ratio is perfect. The staff and owner are super friendly and welcoming.

My favorite item is the shrimp alfredo pizza. If you've never tried one before do yourself a favor and give it a try.

My friends and I get Castello Pizza AT LEAST 3 times a week. Having been lived in the Columbus area for sometime now, I have tried many pizza places and hands down 🙌🙌🙌 THIS IS THE BEST PIZZA I HAVE EVER HAD. I've even traveled to Italy 🇮🇹 and still think that Castello Pizza is better! Great hours, service, and prices. If you're looking for a nice Pizza Restaurant... Castello Pizza is it!

Amazing pizza! I’ve tried their Philly, Margarita, and Alfredo pizza. All were great and the ingredients are obviously fresh & they use good quality cheese. Because of the fresh quality ingredients, their pizza reheats well, so leftovers taste good too! They also have really good garlic dipping sauce.

Pretty good food, much better than the last couple operations in the same building. The guy who served me last was very nice. I've had several things off the menu, and was surprised how good they were (usually a really big menu is a red flag but they seem to pull it off). Definitely worth a try, it's cheap food, not a super upscale place, but the food is higher quality and better prepared than the price suggests.