Karen's Holiday Custard

The custard was very good. Hoagies too

Great food, very nice staff and quick service!

Came here after a baby shower where they had this pizza.
I wanted one to take home for dinner so we took a detour!
We order a pepperoni and mushroom pizza, they never took our name, and said give them 15min. (It was a Sunday afternoon and they only had 1 other person in line, who knows what kind of phone orders.)
That passed and we went in to grab our order. NOTHING. The guy got upset when we didn't have a name to give but showed a receipt. He went in back and never came out. We asked again and were told another 15min. 50min later our pizza was ready for us. We live a hour away so I didn't expect it to be warm. I opened the box and went to put it on a plate and it was doughy! Normally it wouldn't bother me to finish cooking a pizza, I order half baked all the time, but after out wait this was unacceptable.
During our wait we were never even apologized too.
We will try again but

We loved the mom and pop feel. And the food was awesome

Is a pretty great place! Will definitely be going back but probably just for takeout. Hard to enjoy your food when a guy (owner maybe) is sitting in the dining room ranting and raving about Trump this and dumb socialists that. Noone there cares, they just want to relax and enjoy their food. But the food is too good and priced fairly to completley boycott. Oh and great service.