Old Hickory Bar-B-Q Restaurant

Going to start off by saying they were doing great for only being open for 2 months. However, there are still a few kinks to work out. The menu says that you have 4 types of BBQ sauce to choose from, but they only give you the classic. It also states that you get a salad, baked potato, and roll with your meal. They asked which 2 sides we wanted and then brought us corn bread. Nothing major, just a little confusing when you're trying to decide. The food was good for the most part, but the ribs and chicken were very small and didn't have much meat, and the chicken breast filets were slightly overcooked. Also, if you have someone order a meat that needs to be cut, it would be nice to have something other than a butter knife and fork to cut it with - especially when the outside is a little well-done. With all that being said, these are minor issues and kinks that can still be easily fixed. The staff was friendly, and it wasn't busy so we didn't have to wait long. Our food came out quickly, and even though we didn't order any, I noticed the appetizers came out very quickly.

I would definitely go back.

Don't make the same mistake that I did and assume you are going to the Old Hickory on Brown Street. Different atmosphere, different menu. That being said my wife said that her BBQ chicken was great. I am a rib guy and these ribs are very close to the Brown Street ones. Give these people a chance to earn your repeat business. The service was swift and pleasant, food came out in great time and was hot. The house dressing is the same as we are used to and they have the same tangy BBQ sauce I think, if is not the same I liked it anyway. The things that we missed the most were, the bread basket, hash browns with onions, steaks and a cold beer. I would recommend you try these guys. I don't think you will be disappointed. We'll be back and I think this place is good for Brookville. We wish the owners the best of luck.

Just found out they opened up. Gave five stars because I know I'll enjoy it. My wife actually worked for old hickory on main. Chicken is excellent also..just ate there today. Service was excellent, pork tenderloin was very good. Head's up though, home fries were cold and limp. Easy fix if they are aware. Also, personally, I like coke products better but that's just me.

We loved our experience!!! Everyone was very friendly and the food was AMAZING! I had pulled pork and a wedge salad. The pulled pork was tender and moist. The wedge salad is a meal itself.(I’ve had it 3 times). It’s so nice to have a new great place to eat in our small town. Love, love love!