Sugar and Spice

The cutest ice cream place with a bit of outdoor seating and an order window.

So many flavors.

This place has some truly delicious ice cream! I am nearly never in the area. But, I'm sure this place is a classic for the Baldwin/Brentwood/Whitehall community. The vibe it gives is like one of those old school ice cream shops. Local, family owned, and amazing.

I tried the peanut butter milkshake. Super simple, but very good. The number one greatest thing about this place is probably the value. You get a ginormous shake for under $5. And, it was far larger than I have tried in nearly any other place. This sort of value is just incredible.

The flavor is also quite good. I thought it was a little vanilla-y for a peanut butter shake, but still great. You can taste it's homemade, not just Hershey's or some other brand. They also have numerous other standard flavor (chocolate, vanilla, strawberry, and more). They even have frozen yogurt, no sugar added flavors, sundaes, and more.

I'll have to try out some of the more unique flavors sometime; my review would probably be 5 stars by the time I do that. They do close early though (but they are also open year round. Yes, even in the winter). Would love to come back.

Sugar and Spice is one of my favorite neighborhood ice cream shops. I especially like that they have non-dairy options. I got the strawberry swirl and it was excellent. I was very pleased with the service here. The staff was extra friendly and very accommodating. The service was fast and accurate. The atmosphere was very welcoming and enjoyable. You would definitely like it here. I can’t recommend this location highly enough. I would definitely come back here for the great service and nostalgic atmosphere. You certainly will not be disappointed with this wonderful establishment. Definitely stop by if you are in the neighborhood. I definitely will.

We love the hours of operation. They are open late. Great location. Ample parking. Great customer service. Great soda shop atmosphere. Great vibe. Don't be afraid to ask for extra hot fudge!