Keefer's Pizzeria

We got a large pepperoni pizza and I have say it was very delicious. There was a nice amount of toppings and the sauce had a mild sweetness to it that I loved. It was not sour at all, which was a plus. No heartburn here!! The dough was thin crusty and good. They also gave you a dipping garlic butter sauce that was soooo delicious to dip your crust in. The employees were very pleasant to speak to and our order was done pretty fast. I will definitely order from them again. Nice people and fantastic pizza!! Yummmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm🍕

I am glad that this new place opened. We've ordered twice -

1st order ~ A large pepperoni, sausage and extra cheese pizza. The sauce amount was just right since we don't like a lot of sauce. If you do, they will accommodate that for you. I'm a certified "cheese freak", so when I ask for extra cheese, I don't want a few extra slivers of cheese like some places give you. I can say that this was EXTRA CHEESE! LoL I was very pleased. The crust only comes in "thin" which was good too. It wasn't crispy or hard which I know would be some people's concern. While I know that not everyone likes "thin" only, this crust is done in such a way that I highly doubt most will have any problem with at all because the dough is stretched for each order and chewy and tasty.

2nd order ~ Italian hoagie, Keefer's Special Steak hoagie and a Calzone with extra cheese and meatballs ~ everything was uber great. The only thing that might need fixed is the fresh-cut fries and the funnel cake fries were wrapped in foil. The heat created steam which was held in by the foil and made both kinds of fries kinda soggy. I let the owner know, so I'm sure it'll be addressed. Overall, this is our new go-to place to order out.

Wait times are sometimes way longer than necessary. People have told me that they were told to pick up in an hour and then had to wait at the shop for another hour or better when they're busy. Some people have said that their pizza has been burnt, missing toppings or alltogether wrong. Some people have said that they waited for their delivery orders for 2 to 3 hours. I know that all new businesses have to work out things and learn what works and what doesn't so we'll have to stay tuned to how things progress.

Excellent Pizza, Salads, and Wing's that's all I have had 3 or 4 times now.
Reasonable prices.
Excellent Customer Service.
Friendly Staff
Well made evenly topped pizza's baked just right not soggy has good crisp with nice air pockets..
Excellent job Brian and staff
You've earned a regular customer here.
People please support your local businesses.

Awesome chicken salads, hoagies, and pizza. Great service as well. We ordered extra sauce today but didn't get it so I called and spoke to Brian. What a great person to deal with. Can't wait til my next buffalo chicken salad. They have great crust and sauce.