Dutch Haven Shoo-Fly Pie Bakery

Amazing bakery and friendly staff. This is the best shoo fly pie you will ever eat. Highly recommend it.

Dutch haven was not on our list of places to visit but it was open on a Sunday so we gave it a shot. The bakery located in the gift shop was a nice little find. The staff was very friendly. One of the staff members gave us Shoo-Fly pie to try. We had never had, never heard of it. Glad we stopped because it was very good. Several customers in line were buying multiple pies up to 4 at a time. Stop in say hi and give the Shoo-Fly pie a try.

Best shoe fly pie in Lancaster County! No comparison! I tried the chocolate pecan pie and it's dreamy! I actually buy these for my own restaraunt and that chocolate pecan pie gets snatched up immediately. People will come in and buy the entire pie. I cannot keep them in stock. This place has so much to offer outside of pies. Amish furniture, clothing and other gift items. It's just a cool place! The staff is very sweet and always helpful. They clearly love what they do because it shows! Thank you Dutch haven and please keep up the good work! Your pies are truly a slice of heaven!????

Fun tourist trap! I mean that in a good way! They offer samples of the famous shoo fly pie and boy is it sweet! A diabetic coma awaits! The sell a mix of everything, some good some ya gotta wonder... I found my Intercourse PA hat so I was good!

Great pie! Make sure you get the right one cause you have to wait a day to let it harden up to cut and eat it. The employees will tell you. The other stuff is the same thing you'd find at any other tourist locale. Mostly made in China products. Has another store in back with wood built stuff like outdoor furniture and cedar chests. Whether they're locally made or not I'm not sure. I think "Amish Built" is now just a buzzword for wooden built items and quilts. Although you may have better luck finding local made quilts however i don't know or care enough about them to give you much advice.