Catch 22

Food and service was outstanding. Our server, Chad was friendly, attentive and efficient. The fresh catch of the day (Grouper, risotto and asparagus) was awesome. Highly recommend!!

One of the best meals I've had. From the freshly baked bread to the parmesan-crusted scallops to the key lime custard, everything was fresh and flavorful. Service was spot-on, too. I would suggest they improve their website, though; menu is impossible to read online.

Good food and the opposite of for tourists. Service is a decent but the hospitality could use a refresher. A bit to much attention is paid to making reservations for people who never show and not those who are passing potential patrons. Nothing exceptional, but food taste is great and the options are quite acceptable. Overall experience was good, but would likely have been exceptional if the fairly empty (and remained fairly empty) restaurant weren't all full and booked up for the night. But they requested a review so.

We really loved this restaurant. It is a bit tucked away but once you find it, you will be so happy. Our waiter was amazing. He was very informed on the menu & the actual items. Two us had the sea scallops. These were the best scallops I have ever had! The hush puppies are the best on the island. Trust me we tasted them at every restaurant we ate at except of 1 Italian meal. I think I could make a meal of the Hush puppies. We each had a delicious fresh salad. 1 of the group had shrimp which she said very delicious too. They had some nice wine specials too. The restaurant was very pleasantly decorated & very clean. The desserts sounded amazing but we were full. The only thing we are sad about is that we did not go back before we left the island. It was bar none the best meal we had on the island! Bravo!