The Rusty Nail Inn and Tavern

Came here last night and it was a wonderful experience. The food was great and the drinks were too. They've definitely hit the nail on the head (pardon the pun) for what atmosphere they're going for, and I can't wait to see it even more developed. The service was outstanding and I loved how everyone on the staff was dressed up and in character! I will be coming back and will be telling others to do the same! Everyone should tell everyone they know, I wanna see this place go straight to the top!

I went to The Rusty Nail Inn and Tavern for the first time today (24 August 21). All I can say is, wow! I wasn't super hungry, so my wife and I didn't try the meat board. However, I was not disappointed by the chicken, bacon, ranch pizza. It's a perfect size, there was plenty of cheese and toppings. Everything was quite fresh. I know there will always be naysayers, but, I had no complaints! The staff does a fantastic job with the "theme" or "role" they are partaking in. Very friendly staff and a highly unique atmosphere. I will gladly make my way back in the very near future!

LOVE LOVE LOVE THIS PLACE! My family and I frequent the tavern, you definitely never know what to expect with employees OR the food, in the most awesome way. Meat boards are a favorite, no two are the same. Always friendly faces and delicious food.

Have been to the this establishment numerous times since their opening. The owner, Susan aka Madam Malavent, is a wonderful hostess equipped with a sunny disposition, infectious laugh, and top notch staff. The daily specials I’ve tried have been unique and delicious while their signature drinks are both far too easy to consume and easy on the wallet.

Themed events and a playful, fantasy tinged atmosphere have turned this lovely tavern into a weekly stop for fun, food, and great company. I highly recommend it!

We went as a party of four to dine at this fine tavern. The hearty meal and excellent mead offer wayfarers much needed respite in their travels.

But jokes aside, the atmosphere here is excellent and really makes you feel as if you're in a tavern in a fantasy world. We have been twice now as a table of four and both times ordered the large meat and cheese tray. The keyword here is "large". This thing is huge! The meats and cheeses are all Boar's Head, and there is a variety of produce (some or all of which is local), hummus, and other delicious additions.

I highly recommend this location for anyone who is into Dungeons & Dragons, Lord of the Rings, or any other medieval fantasy-themed fiction.

Finally, the duels are also very entertaining. Unfortunately, I am bound secrecy, so you will need to see one (or participate in one) yourself!