Mystic BBQ & Grill

First time and couldn’t be happier! Such an improvement over the previous owner. The ribs are excellent as was the crab cake sandwich. Our server Monika was very genuine and good. We will definitely be returning soon.

Mystic BBQ is an Old Town hidden gem! I came here with my friends and we had a great time. The staff were kind and helpful, and they have great suggestions! I am pescatarian, but there are lots of fish options. I had the Shrimp Po Boy, which I will be coming back for. As a lover of mac and cheese, I can truly say that Mystic’s is one of the best I’ve had, and deserves to be an entree. I honestly would’ve taken it home and eaten it for the next three days if there was any left. Their Cobb salad is delicious and filling, which is hard to say for most salads in my experience! Mystic is a great spot to stop by for hearty food and drinks, and I will definitely be returning!

A Memorable Dining Experience at Mystic BBQ & Grill

My recent visit to Mystic BBQ & Grill was an absolute delight from start to finish. The experience began with two incredible appetizers: Fried Green Tomatoes topped with lump crab and drizzled with a tangy lemon-habanero comeback sauce, and the Gumbo Ya YA, featuring wood-grilled chicken and andouille sausage. The lemon-habanero sauce perfectly enhanced the flavor of the crispy fried green tomatoes, adding a zesty kick that was simply divine. The Gumbo Ya YA transported me straight to New Orleans with its authentic taste and rich, flavorful broth. Both appetizers were fresh and bursting with flavor.

For our main course, we enjoyed the Jumbo Lump Crab Sandwich and the Mystic Baby Back Ribs. The Jumbo Lump Crab Sandwich was outstanding, with generous portions of crab and minimal filler, complemented beautifully by crisp lettuce and a flavorful Florida mustard sauce. The Mystic Baby Back Ribs were another highlight – tender, expertly seasoned, and lightly coated with a delectable BBQ sauce that didn't overpower the meat's natural flavors.

The staff at Mystic BBQ & Grill were friendly, attentive, and made us feel right at home. The atmosphere was pleasant and laid-back, perfect for a relaxing meal. The restaurant was clean and bright, further enhancing our dining experience.

Overall, Mystic BBQ & Grill exceeded our expectations in every way. From the fresh, flavorful dishes to the welcoming ambiance and top-notch service, it’s a place I’ll definitely be returning to. Highly recommended!

Fantastic restaurant. Great atmosphere, friendly staff that makes you feel at home, and most importantly the food rocks. They have awesome traditional BBQ option with a fun mix of some of Ralph Davis’s signature recipes that are local favorites such as She Crab Soup and Crab Cake Sandwich. A must visit!

Had dinner there Friday night. Food and service were both excellent. The Spicy Chicken sandwich special had good moisture and decent amount of spice. The Alabama white sauce was my favorite of the sauces I tried. It had nice acidity and plenty of pepper. The house sauce was good, too.
The staff was friendly and service was great.