Oystercatcher

You’ll wish the night will never end! I can’t stop thinking about the food, the presentation, and our great server, Aaron (thanks for a wonderful night!!). My wife and I dined here for our anniversary and we both agree that the food and experience was absolutely amazing and unforgettable. There aren’t many words that I can put here that will do this place justice. This place is definitely worthy of five stars. If you are looking for an amazing dining experience that you will *never* forget, this is the place! We will definitely go back again and again!

Hands down our favorite restaurant on the island. The service is attentive and personable, but entirely unpretentious. The food is incredible. Quality, fresh ingredients, treated with impeccable skill and care. The bread is fantastic. With all this, the prices are still very reasonable for what you get.

We recommend the oystercatcher to anyone with culinary interest. It rivals Michelin starred restaurants at a fraction the price, and is a perfect hidden gem.

Delicious farm-to-table fare. Always a little varied and outstanding flavors presented simply yet tastefully. Service is superb - friendly and attentive. Definitely recommend.

Polished local bistro bustling with friendly energetic staff. Hyper-local menu doesn't disappoint with an excellent selection of starters and solid main courses. Small but well curated wine list and a sophisticated cocktail list. Recommended.

We enjoyed the duck breast and steak. The small duck soup starter they give you was interesting and my girlfriend loved the chamomile sorbet palate cleanser. The complimentary bread was incredible, we ended up buying a loaf. We weren't a fan of the ice cream sandwich dessert, but still a great night overall. Our server Aaron was excellent. Recommended!