Toby's Supper Club

Amazing food. The steak was so tender it was unbelievable. The service was awesome too. Dinner was even topped off with some amazing cinnamon rolls. Definitely try this place.

Great Friday night fish fry! Fun place to hang out with friends while you wait for a table. Sports on TV and great drinks!!

Its a little loud and usually crowded, but if go there knowing that, it just added to the experience.

Had a surprise birthday dinner here tonight and it was fantastic. The food, the atmosphere, the employees. Everything was spot on.

And if you're into fruity drinks, don't forget to try the Key Lime Pie Martini. It is AMAZING.

A very popular old style Supper Club! You order before you are seated. When your meal is ready the waitress will come get you. Be prepared to wait but it's worth it!

We have just moved to Madison from NE Wisconsin and were lucky to have enjoyed Mark's East Side for fish fries for the last few years. While this fish fry is very comparable to theirs and perhaps may be better, unfortunately the overall experience lowers the rating.

We arrived at 5:15 and expected there to be a wait. We had read the reviews online and knew we needed to get there as early as possible. The bar was full, but we were able to get our names on the list within 10 minutes. So far so good, we got our drinks and waited....and waited. It was 6:45 by the time we were seated.

Once we got our food, we realized the long wait. The perch is probably the best I have ever had. I tried my wife's cod and it was very good too. French fries were hot and delicious. The tartar sauce and coleslaw were tremendous!

We left the restaurant at about 7:30. Although the meal was great, I'm not sure if we will return. If we do, we will get there right at 5 and attempt to get our order in ASAP. Be prepared to wait is my biggest piece of advice.