Eat the Best Pizza

Eat the Best Pizza is a hidden gem that gives Ian's a run for its money. Every time I walk by, the pizza smells make my mouth water. It's open until 4AM every day, and not horrifically crowded like Conrad's Grill or Ian's Pizza tend to get on weekend nights (because not enough people know about it). It serves massive slices of thin-crust New York pizza that you might want to fold in half to eat. The pizza is delicious and ready quickly, the selection of slices is good (although not quite as varied as Ian's), and the prices are very reasonable.

This place has stopped me from starving on multiple occasions when I was burning the midnight oil on assignments, and I could not be more grateful that it exists. Lives up to its name.

Best garlic rolls I've ever had. Staff toasts six homemade rolls each time you order, lightly crisping the edges before they get slathered with a fresh garlic butter and a pinch of parmesean, not a dash of cheap garlic salt to be found!

Pizza comes in a BIG wide slice with a crust tossed thin in the center and thick & chewy for the crust. Definitely recommend folding your slice NY style and eating it that way.

Dough is perfectly salted as well, if you're sick of cheap garlic salt and looking for authentic Italian pizza this is your place!

I like hole in the wall pizza places but not all are equal and good. Had low expectations when I walked in and thought "is this an Ian's rip off?" As I saw Mac and cheese pizza and buffalo chicken...but then I picked the white pizza slice and when I took my first bite, I knew this was it. Crispy bottom.. flavorful toppings. Get here and try it out!

Very friendly people and easily the best pizza I've had in Madison! Great by-the-slice selections that rotate daily. The lasagna pizza, as other reviewers have mentioned, is particularly tasty, and the chicken/bacon/ranch, meat lovers, etc are all top-notch! Much better than Ians, the other local option for pizza on State St, which is overpriced, takes forever, and doesn't taste particularly good.