1847 at the Stamm House

Went here for our 4th wedding anniversary and liked the food very much. The crabcakes were packed full if tasty crab and only enough filler to hold them together. I would get them again for sure. Me and the husband both got steak and were happy with the texture and flavor. Very good cuts of meat and no sinewy stringy bits. Good portion sizes and nice staff. The one slight mistake with my order was fixed very fast. I also appreciated that they had a handout with the buildings history.

New Experience -⭐⭐⭐⭐
Overall, I like the new menu. Cheese Curds were a disappointment for WI so I will definitely be trying something new next time. More potato options should be offered for steaks or dinner dishes. I also think the cooks should learn what a carmelized onion is. If it's on the menu, know it.

Prior Experience - ⭐
My wife and I live near the Stamm House and were excited about the reopening of the restaurant. We waited 3 weeks after the opening hoping the opening rush would mellow a little. We did not know they recommended a reservation though they were able to seat us right away. After that it was all down hill. We were told our waiter would be over soon. Soon turned into 20 minutes later. He apologized for the wait and he took our drink order. He was about to walk away when we quickly said we were ready to order food as well. 20 minutes to read a small, small, very small menu. You would think your mind would be made up in that long sit talking about butter, right?? Now my patience was really being tested. It took another 20 minutes to receive the drinks!!! 45 minutes after receiving the drinks we finally got our food. We ordered another round of drinks. They never came back until we were done. I looked at the receipt and they charged us for the drinks we never got! I am now %!$$#@. No second round. No checking in. Both our burgers were not right. I am so upset with this place I am shocked they are still doing business. When I asked for the manager, the guy never came over. I honestly think you owe us a better experience. But after being brushed off, I know they don't care. It is also sad that most people I speak to have also had bad experiences there.

Delicious food. Probably my new favorite cheese curds. And such a unique location! Our waiter was great as well. 5 stars

Friendly bar and waitstaff, warm and beautiful old place, recently restored. Excellent food, loved the Lasagna and the brussel sprout app! Recommended highly, we will be back again with friends.....

I was very impressed by Stamm House. They did an incredible job renovating the historic property. The food flavor was outstanding and service was top notch. I'm really glad to see this place is part of Madison Originals. That made me try it and fall in love.