Hubbard Avenue Diner

Love Hubbard Avenue Diner! My aunt introduced us to it a few years ago before she died, so now we visit every time we're in Wisconsin from Georgia. The food and service have been consistently good, and the pie is amazing! I've tried nearly every type in the place, and the only time I wasn't 100% satisfied was when I ordered the S'mores taco. Even then, it was tasty...just too crumbly for my taste. Love the diner and will continue to have a meal there when we're in town!

Good diner food, chill atmosphere, allergy friendly options with knowledgeable staff, accommodate children. We usually LOVE Hubbard Ave, but the past couple times service has been hit or miss. This time we had to ask for a server after everyone around us had their orders taken. And after we finally ordered, our server forgot a drink, which I had to go up and ask for, and then never came back to the table. I know this isn't the norm and we'll definitely be back

I've never had a bad experience here. Food is always good, the service is quick, and did I mention that the food was good? If you like pies, you need to come here. If there's not a flavor for you then you don't like pies. They have over 800 flavors. (not all at once of course) I've never had breakfast here but from the sound of it, it would be delicious.

Cute little place! Good food, fair prices, and they donated a bunch of "pie coupons" to a swim meet we attended in Middleton yesterday. Really generous, thank you!!

Food is good but service is always lacking. I have to look around for my waiter/waitress every time I need something. There doesn't seem to be very much checking up on the customer. I often need a refill that never happens before I'm finished with my food. The food is good though, so I come back.