Wild Tomato Wood-Fired Pizza and Grille Sister Bay

We had supreme pizza, chicken strips, and onion strings. All tasty. Ava our server was great! Their drink menu is limited but lots of craft options and sangria. Inside and outside seating. Pretty large menu and it all sounded good.

First time up to door county, and on the first night we chose wild tomato as a second option. In the future, it will be a first option. Pizza was amazing, with the sauce being robust, perfectly portioned toppings, and a beautifully baked crust. The service was excellent as well and staff was polite, fast, and accurate. Absolutely loved it. Will reccomend this to my family who comes up here every summer!

Stopped for lunch and some
Cocktails after the beach and exploring. Great location and well laid out place with a nice atmosphere. Our waitress, Lola, was great and the basil mint cider was quite tasty. Food was solid, cheese curds, pizza, jerked chicken bowl....all yummy. Definitely recommend.

Was so excited to find a pizza place that not only does wood fired pizzas but also offers goat cheese and vegan cheese options...very rare!

Love the atmosphere...plenty of seating options in the dining room, inside and outside bar areas, and patio complete with umbrellas and patio string lights. Only complete is the super small metal chairs...made for tight seating for anyone with a little bit of hips or bottom!

Food was really good and price was reasonable. Ordered large deluxe and large pepperoni/pineapple/goat cheese pizzas along with 4 drinks and came in under $60.

Super fun and will be back again soon.

Seating was immediate as we wished to eat outdoors. The weather was beautiful at 74 degrees at 6pm in Sister Bay. Staff was courteous & attentive. Place was moderately busy when we arrived & very busy when we left. We ordered the Paisano Pizza & it was the best pizza I’ve had that I can remember. Very fresh tasting. There is not a choice of crust but we loved it. Not thick & not thin, cardboard type either. There are other options besides pizza but the pizza reviews have been very good so pizza it was. Good selection of non-alcoholic & alcoholic beverages. Appeared clean & kept up. Also offer a few dessert choices. We look forward to trying other pizza flavors here.