Nightingale Supper Club

Wow, my steak was cooked to perfection and the soup is to die for. Wonderful, friendly service and the complimentary cheese platter was a lovely addition whilst waiting in the bar for my table. Highly recommended for a fabulous meal.

A longstanding family favorite! Their bar is always so welcoming and, in the Supper Club tradition, appropriate for the whole family. Great cocktails and a wide selection of regional and specialty dishes from sandwiches to full dinners. This is one of the top places for perfectly seasoned, perfectly done Prime Rib, but all of their food is outstanding! Couldn't even finish writing this review without having my mouth water.

This place is my jam. The friendly bartender engaged us while we waited to sit. He turned out to be the owner and it turned out to be the best prime rib of all time. Great server and atmosphere

This is one of those places I always take my out of town visitors to show off the area. The service is amazing. I splurged on the surf and turf tonight and it did not disappoint. The lobster was light and melt in my mouth good. My steak was a perfect medium-rare, just as I'd requested. Also had the Sturgeon Bay Breeze drink and it was a delight as well.

My son and husband loved there steaks! To me it was a little salty. But was still good! Our waitress was great! Called ahead before we got there. Just had to wait about 5 minutes. We all had the garlic mashed potato. The best we have ever had. And we all ways get them. At other restaurants. Wish I would of gotten some to go! For sure will be back! Will job. Our hotel told us about this place.