Fireside Supper Club

Found this little gem right after I got in town. Great food, and a pretty good price as well. Definitely was not hungry when I left. Pretty nice atmosphere also

Excellent Supper Club dining experience! Bread basket, salad & soup, main entree & side dish. Excellent Food & selection!

New ownership is awesome! Fireside has become an annual tradition for my wife and I over the last 9 years we've gone to the Northwoods together (she's been going for 30, so she has high standards for supper clubs). Although we've gone primarily for the sunset view and cozy bar in past years, this year we were blown away by the quality of the food and service. We went relatively late on a slow Wednesday night (around 8pm). We noticed new art on the menu cover, but inside it looked like all of the same options were there. On the back of the menu, we noticed that they have new ownership after some 30 years under previous owners, but the the goal has been to keep the menu the same. They've done that while also boosting the quality of everything coming out of the kitchen and bar. My lake perch and my wife's baked walleye were both absolutely perfect. Presentation was beautiful. No sloppy pool of butter on the plate, and the fish was cooked to a perfect flake. Our Old Fashions from the bar were superb--their mix seems to be better this year. And after dinner, our server kindly served us another round even though we were the last table in the restaurant (something we didn't notice right away.) He brought us our drinks without ever conveying a sense of wanting to get us out of there. We didn't linger long, but we will definitely be back. Thank you so much to the new owners for keeping the great atmosphere and raising the quality of food and service at this amazing supper club.

My husband and I have been dining here for over 20 years. There was a time several years ago that we gave up on Fireside. The service has always been great but the food was not always so good. We decided to give them another chance and we were not disappointed. It was extremely busy and we were told there was an hour wait. We were seated in less than 45 minutes. The staff is amazing. People all around us were raving about the fish fry. We opted to try something different. My husband ordered the pork chops and it was so tender and juicy. I had the rib eye. We were both stuffed and could not finish our meals. The rib eye was quite possibly the best steak I have ever eaten. I highly recommend this place.

After ten years of not going there because of poor management and iffy food, we gave it a try. New management, great service, thank you Donna, and outstanding food.
The prices were reasonable. The steak was spot on medium rare. The homemade soups were great. They even brought out a huge piece of wonderful carrot cake for our anniversary. If you haven't been there recently, go
You will be pleased that you did.