The Alumni Club Tavern & Eatery

We stopped at the Alumni Club for the first time on a Saturday afternoon with a group of three. I had the "Tachos" or tator-tot nachos which were really good! My fiance and his brother were there too and they both had wraps which they both finished. They have a large selection of beers both bottled and tap. The restaurant also boasts it's many TVs and they had the Brewer Game on as well as some college football that day. The atmosphere is casual with sports memorabilia from the Menomonee Falls area around the restaurant as well as an open garage door for the front wall which is open to the downtown area when the weather is nice enough. I would definitely go back again for higher end "bar food" with even a few healthier options.

The Alumni Club is just what Menomonee Falls needed, it is such a welcoming place! Love the atmosphere, and the food! We have had phenomenal service! Will definitely keep coming back.

Well done restaurant and bar. Open seating even a lower level for extra seating and parties. Watch it under construction as I live nearby and couldn’t wait. Will definitely be back for the service and atmosphere. Great job

Did a great job remodeling. A cut above the many dive bars in the Falls. Service needs work for sure. Waited at least 10 min to get waited on at a table although admittedly it was busy. And when our food came we didn't get silverware or the water I asked for. Hopefully they work that out soon. The pizza comes on a cardboard disc like a frozen pizza. While I have seen that before, it is not an image that fits the nice decor. Also while the pizza was decent, it lacked oregano which would be an inexpensive fix. Drink prices fair.