Cornerstone Sports Pub & Eatery

I enjoyed a really good burger & homemade tots! Prices are fair and service excellent. In Oconomowoc, stop here to enjoy a snack or meal while watching the game.

Service is super slow every time we come, but the food is good.

After a couple people randomly tell me Cornerstone has the best burger in town, I decide I gotta go.

Got a simple cheeseburger with cheddar and fries. Fries were crinkle cut and delicious, as they should be. Nice and hot, no major oil taste. Burger was delicious. Beef was tender like ground sirloin but wasn't dry. Perfect medium temperature. Bun was fresh and fantastic.

Service was friendly as timely. I'll be back.

** Note: My father ate there twice recently and had old oil flavor in fries and onion strings. Maybe it was a fluke and they didn't change oil soon enough. Also, our sodas were flat. We will overlook for now.

We eat there several times a year, always has friendly staff. The food comes quickly and is always the correct temperature. The portions are satisfying, the menu has many options and their nightly specials are priced right. Our favorite is the grilled chicken sandwich on grilled sourdough. I tried an old fashioned and it was as good as an "up north" supper club. Parking in back. Highly recommend!

UPDATE:

Tried it again for a Friday fish fry. Normal wait time. If you are looking to avoid the rush, it seems that 7:00 would be the sweet spot for that.

As for the food, fish fry was great, and all the sides were just as good. No complaints with it!

Best part this visit was the server. I will call out Kassi as a kick butt server! She was hands down the best waitress I have had in a long time! She made sure to check back multiple times, and was on things. Even if she didn't need to refill things, she'd at least touch the table so we knew that she was looking and checking in on us. She made sure we were all taken care of with all of her tables, and was running laps around others. She was redeemed the service from the first visit below! Thank you Kassi!!

--------------------------_------

We arrived after the main dinner rush. We're seated after a few minutes, which the two ladies told us when we put in our name. When we got seated our waitress was right there, placed our drink order and we got them immediately.

It was our first time here so we wanted to look over the menu, and our waitress was kind enough to give us some time. However, I think she forgot we were her table. She walked by us numerous times, bussing tables and assisting others bring out food, and walking out and down the hallway. Finally i had to ask another waitress to send ours over because it had been a good 15 minutes since I placed my menu next to me, to try and signify we were ready.

When the waitress came she was apologetic. We placed our fish order and had it within 5 minutes, which was decimating up for being forgotten about. The fish was rubbery and didn't flake apart like you'd expect it to. The fries were phenomenal though, I could go for a plate of just those.

Overall it wasn't the worst, I want to give it another try because there was a lot of good sounding items, just not the greatest first time experience. We will give it another try, and maybe the rating will go up from a 3 star.