Fat Sully's - Tennyson

Even though we showed up pretty late, the staff were SUPER kind and awesome. The slices were huge, delicious, affordable, and came out super fast (think Costco sizes and prices but way tastier). I absolutely will come back!

Any time I'm hit with a craving for NY-style pizza, the only option that makes any sense to me whatsoever is Fat Sully's. Their little takeout window is genius and open late, which is super appealing for us night-owls. They use amazing black olives, the big fat chunky variety and not those measly, shriveled little rings that taste of nothing. Sometimes I've ordered very close to closing time and instead of getting just the one or occasionally two slices that I paid for, they've given me an extra one for no charge. Once, I even got two bonus slices! Pretty awesome!

I lived in NYC for ten years and definitely know what I like when it comes to this style of pizza - Fat Sully's hits the nail on the head and I'm really happy to live a convenient distance from one! Thanks for the great 'za!

Awesome atmosphere, pizza, beer, good size crowd. Deals on beer and pizza slices. Pizza slices are huge, filling, and actually really good! Bartenders seemed awesome, I was there on a trivia night so that seemed cool. Check it out!

Best Dang Pizza I've Ever Had!! We got the 20 inch half pepperoni half meats with extra cheese and it is so mouth watering AMAZING! The crust is so soft that my kids and husband actually ate it, and you can taste the smokey flavors of the bacon. The Italian sausage is the best I've had on a pizza, my family and I devoured the pie! If I could give this place a billion stars I would. ☺