The Pie Maker Bakery

We stayed in Cortez, CO on our way to Mesa Verde and I looked up a bakery to stop at. The Pie Maker had great reviews and looked friendly! They were open for order pickups on Saturday, we were there on Tuesday. I reached out before we left on our road trip and they stayed in touch with me and we arranged a time I could pick up our order.

The mini strawberry-rhubarb pies are great you’ll taste both flavors! The mini apple pie crumble is crunchy and there’s a little extra cinnamon kick with the apples. We also got some cookies. The molasses cookies were awesome, and the peanut butter cookies deserve a big glass of milk! Excellent customer care and friendly shop!

Really lovely bakery and Cafe where everything is house made using many local and organic ingredients. No espresso machine but several house made cold brew options on a nitro tap as well as teas. My bagel was pretty good, I would have preferred more toasting, and the green chilie cream cheese was v tasty. I ended up blending the vanilla and honey cold brews for a unique and delicious eye opening drink.

Outstanding bakery with delicious cakes and bagel sandwiches, plus awesome nitro coffee. Recommended!

Small but crowd-pleasing selection of sweet and savory treats. Coffee is VERY strong!

Very friendly local coffee house with cold brew coffee infused with nitrogen - amazingly smooth and tasty! They have a light menu with bagels, sandwiches, quiches, and sweet baked goods. And of course they make excellent pie.