Gatsby's Pizza

Met Greg as we came in a bit early for our order of two pizzas. Greg was an extremely friendly fellow and pleasant to talk to. He's got quite a story if you take the time to hear it. Pizza was thin crust and amazing-- and we're from NY so that's high standards to achieve! We closed our vacation up with this place as our last meal and couldn't have picked a better place.

Eating Gatsby's Pizza right now. Just had a great conversation with the owner who is absolutely delightful and friendly. We're from NY, and I will say- this is not NY Style pizza. It is entirely different, but delicious in its own right. Thin and crispy and loaded with super fresh toppings. The slices are tiny squares instead of the standard triangle- which means I probably ate too many too fast without realizing it, lol. It is yummy.
We did carry out, but there were a few tables in the restaurant. Everything seemed clean and it was nicely decorated. And did I mention friendly? I will definitely return here on our next trip to Florida. Thank you, Greg, for your hospitality!

An old tried and true establishment reopened. The pizza is as good as ever and better than any other I've tried. Greg Gzstby, the owner always great you with a warm hello and makes you feel like an old dear friend. He puts his love into every part of the business and it shows. If you really love pizza it's a dining delight.

Loved the pizza! Thin and Crispy with light sauce. Reasonably priced.

Jackie greeted us upon arrival and Greg shared his amazing story of perserverance with brain cancer.

Fantastic Pizza!

Read about this place in the newspaper and had to check it out because of the story behind the owners. Cute little place with a homey atmosphere. Small menu but it's perfect. The pizza is delicious! The crust is thin and crunchy. Personal recipe; same with the sauce made fresh daily. Greg the owner visited tables and is sooo happy to be making pizzas again. You MUST check it out!