Holeman and Finch

I came into Holeman & Finch with high expectations for their famous burger, but I was honestly a little letdown. The burger is a double patty with cheese, pickles, and onions. The burger was not bad, but definitely not great in my opinion. My first issue was when I realized that the burger didn’t have lettuce and tomato on it, which I consider essential. When I requested lettuce and tomato from the server, he was really nice and brought me lettuce but told me the restaurant didn’t have tomatoes because they aren’t in season (haven’t seen that stop every other restaurant serving burgers). My second issue was that I really couldn’t taste any flavor from the cheese. Finally, I was disappointed by the ketchup. I’m not sure what type of ketchup they serve, but it definitely isn’t standard and to me had an odd aftertaste. These are the reasons that the burger didn’t live up to my expectations, but I should mention that the beef and bun were good quality. My boyfriend enjoyed his burger more than me, and I think this is because he likes meaty flavors, while I prefer a combination of flavors when I’m eating a burger. The saving aspect of the meal was the fries. They were amazing!! Perfectly crispy on the outside and soft on the inside.

The overall ambiance of the restaurant was okay but felt a little cramped. The servers were courteous and quick with their service. I will not likely return since I didn’t love the burger, but it might be worth trying if you’re interested in developing own opinion about their famous burger.

Update: over the last year quality of everything here has suffered as they prepare to leave this location. It remains to be seen if they re-attain their former glory once they are in Colony Square.

Previous review: Best mixologists in the city! Definitely the place to go if you want to get adventurous in the offal, because they do it right, but they do everything else well too.

I had some trout it was so-so, I had to think about my rating a bit because technically my experience there was fine. I'm going going to go ahead and say it.. This place is a bit expensive for what you get. I thought the fish I ate was weak and the greens I had were actually horrible, like nobody would like these, they were tasteless. The appetizers and cheese etc were very good but honestly.. for my wife and I it was a 130$ meal and there are MANY places I'd rather spend that money on than here.. I wish I had gotten the burger but if all this place is is an expensive burger place there are other places I'd rather do that at too. Overall, the things other than the main meal were good... overall I was left a little unsatisfied.

This place is INCREDIBLE! The new waitress was wonderful. Our drinks never got below 3/4 full. Great buy for all of the food we received. Menu was very unique and impressive. Something for every taste. My personal recommendations

One of the best places. Restaurant is small and chic.I mainly get the burger and fries when I visit, but it is probably one of the best burgers you'll have. Nothing extra, but its the details of how well the burger is cooked. Also was treated to some nice rolls with garlic pickles for an appetizer. Nice dining experience.