Il Castello

Okay first off HOW CUTE IS THIS PLACE? Really nice staff. A special shout-out to Leslie for being one of the kindest souls in Barryville. She treated us beautifully and always with a smile. The knots are surprisingly great - not too dry - and the pizza was nice. Will definitely come back next time we are in Barryville.

Our first time in the area and it was the perfect place for lunch! Perfect portions and absolutely delicious.

This place has been a staple in my and my families lives for well over 10 years. So much so, while living in North Carolina this was the first place we would come to while visiting

Pizza and pasta are always a safe bet here, but you can't go wrong with much on the menu.

Pizza is sold by the slice with a ton of options. Specials and pricing are fair and don't really change.

Cash, credit and debit accepted here.

The owners Pete and Kelly do so much to help the neighborhood and community.

While it is not the "only place in town" it is practically the only place in town to get an acceptable meal at normal meal hours. The menu has all of the regular pizza/Italian restaurant items you would expect at very reasonable prices. Lots of seating and good service.

We have a summer cottage in Blooming Grove PA and was always looking for some place new to eat. We looked on google maps and found Il Castello in NY only a 25 minute drive away. The car ride through the beautiful PA country roads and down along the Delaware river was so relaxing. We visited here on a Wednesday afternoon in late June. They have a nice little patio area with tables and umbrellas but unfortunately, it was not opened when we visited.
Our party ordered a meatball hoagie, pizza, fries, wings and drinks. The plate of fries they brought I had to take home with me there was so much. Very crispy and light and not over salted like some places. The pizza was a little thicker crust but crisp and cheesy. Very good. Meatballs were a nice size as well as the wing bites. Everything we had was delicious and we will be coming back to eat here again.