Icarus Sandwich Shop

I placed an order online for 5 sandwiches, 2 chips, and 1 drink. The sandwiches were delicious. However, I am not happy about the forced gratuity because of the dollar value of the order. It would have been nice if it flagged explaining the reasoning behind the gratuity. Next time we will place our orders separately to avoid the gratuity.

You may be asking yourself “do these sandwiches warrant a ~$15 price point (with no sides)?” Unfortunately the answer is no, especially when compared to local competition. While the staff is wonderful and the sandwiches are delicious, they aren’t all that special. There’s very limited seating here (actually feels more like a waiting room), so you can’t even write it off as a dining experience since you’ll likely have to take your sandwich to-go. Once the novelty of the shop being new wears off, I figure it will be difficult to get any regulars. Hopefully the prices will come down soon.

Third time was a charm (the first two visits they were sold out)! Did not disappoint. I got the meatball sandwich - like a beautiful meatball/meatloaf combo. Delicious. And I didn't eat my sandwich until two hours later and it was still hot. Congrats - will be back for more and ice cream!

The meatball and spicy soppressata sandwiches are incredible, the chips and onion dip were delicious, and the vanilla/pineapple swirl soft serve is amazing. There’s a lot to love about this place for sure. I love the name and aesthetics of the logos a lot. The place is a bit small so there isn’t much seating inside, but the kitchen/expo/register system they seem to have with the staff seems to run smoothly which is a great feat of a new place; everyone is super friendly and is working hard. We’ll be back for sure, there are a lot of delicious sounding/looking things on the menu.

I cannot say enough good things about this place! I live close by, so was very excited that the owners of Fox in the Snow were opening up something new at this convenient location. Literally try anything, it's all so good! I got the Turkey BLT and Italian-ish and both amazing. Will be my new weekly spot :)