Carmella's Plates & Pints

Terrific classy place with a unique charm. Warm and friendly, the ambiance is wild west with Pittsburgh charm. The menu is all game-based with elk bison and very unique appetizers. Beer menu is excellent The drinks menu is fantastic, but be prepared for a bit of a higher price on all the menu items. It's an excellent place to go for a different kind of meal, but I wouldn't eat here on a regular basis due to the cost. However I would drink here on a regular basis as they are very reasonable and creative with the offerings. I would review the menu prior to going but definitely go once.

I have had everything on there menu and it has all been fantastic. There specials have always been top notch. There new seasonal menu with the Elk, Bison, and butternut risotto. It was all Spectacular

Great place to go for food and drinks. Whiskey selection is awesome and the food is always good. I always end up with the scallops. Cooked perfectly each time.

The ambiance is unique for the Southside. Love it!

They really pride themselves on being more locally sourced and you can taste the difference. The meat is so fresh and flavorful that I start getting sad when I'm on my last few bites. The drinks are really fun too! They have a bunch of cocktails and fruit infused liquors that make every visit different.

I absolutely love this place. I have been several times and have never had a bad dish. Everything I have ordered from this restaurant has been delicious to the point of wanting more! If you like Eggs Benedict- the Scallops Benedict is worth a try. Each time I have had it, it’s been remarkable!