The Old Whiskey Mill

We first came here back in October 2019. The service was outstanding but the food absolutely was not. We had a large group of people..and nobody was satisfied with their meal. Now...fast forward to March 2020..we gave it another try. Our server (I wish I could remember her name) was amazing, friendly, attentive and told us fun places to visit on our short stay here. Food was delicious and drinks were great and quick. Came back again a few days later and were lucky to get our same favorite server who remembered us. Food again was delicious, drinks quick and enoyed a wonderful dinner!!

Seated right away, ordered drinks. Appetizer was a sausage platter with mustard and cabbage. I had the surf and turf... AMAZING! Also, I needed to modify my order due to being diabetic, and they did so cheerfully, which is much appreciated. I will absolutely be coming here again!

Wonderful selection of rye whiskey and Bourbon, try the Manhattans or old fashioned drinks. The food is great too. The bangers and mash is awesome and the service is amazing. Prices are reasonable and you are in Port Townsend so enjoy the fare and sight see and shop to walk it off????

Had a really good experience here. The food was delicious and the servings were generous. The ambiance was nice and so was the service. The only reason I’m giving this 4 and not 5 stars is because the menus were so faded you could barely read them in some places. However, I will definitely return and would recommend.

A Favorite! Took a few weeks to get "in the groove", when the new owner took over this spot but, it is up to full par, now. Excellent food, well prepared and fresh, great specials, very creative. Awesome staff... with only one exception, every one there is friendly, attentive, just awesome! Great place for a meal or just a drink , beers and watch a ballgame.