Indian Creek Steakhouse

Rural style steakhouse in downtown Caldwell has a bit of a roadhouse feel with main dining area connected to an expansive bar, live music area. Huge projection TV and pool table as well. Decorated throughout with a western, hunting theme. Our party of 7 was greeted and seated immediately. Was impressed to see an open fire grill and the aroma was great. Waited a bit for my drink order that came incorrectly. Appetizers of fried pickles, cheese curds, and fried prawns were all tasty. Main courses of steak, fried steak fingers, and chicken. The steak was a bit subpar as reviews from the table included overdone fillet, and dry ribeye. The steak fingers were tough to bite through and chewy. Downtown Caldwell felt festive with the Holiday lights still up. Although it was impressive to see so many cars downtown Caldwell on a Tuesday night, parking was a bit of a challenge.

Had lunchtime tri-tip. It was done perfectly. Tender, cooked just right. Smoked, I do believe. Delicious. This place has a lot of incredible sights within. There must be alot of history behing it!

The food was 👍 great 👍! The atmosphere was amazing, and we even watched people line dance starting around 7:30pm.

Right when I walked in I got greeted with hellos and smiles. Staff all very nice. Fries not crispy but they are freshly made. Fried pickles are pretty good. My favorite was the salad. Had it with blue cheese dressing was a bit mild but not bad.

Service was a little slow i’d say and the food wasn’t THAT great. I got salmon and a fully loaded baked potato and i did enjoy those! The water though, the worst tap i’ve ever tasted