Carriage House

Just a wonderful experience! 10 out of 10! Yes this restaurant was expensive but few things are worth every penny. The lamb was fantastic. Perfectly seasoned and cooked. I tried both the martinis and they were so good. They have an alcohol milkshake that was very tasty. We finished with the lemon Marianne pie. So good. The service was top notch!

Girls, if you are on the island, come to dine here! Guys, take your girl (or mom) here to impress her! Not only the view is fantastic, the garden is gorgeous, but even the restroom is pretty!! I mean it! This is the first ever restroom that I take pictures. The food was great, too. The lobster tails that my husband ordered had crispy shell that smelled like grilled not baked (I don’t really know how it was done, just guessing). My white fish was steamed and so were the potatoes, healthy and good for keeping shape. The price is relatively high, but not more expensive than other restaurants that have live piano playing, you know. After all, I think it is worthy of the view and experience. What a memorable place!

I got to experience dinner here recently and I loved new it. Our server made sure our drinks were made specifically for our liking. She even recommended their nonalcoholic drinks for my pregnant wife which she loved.

The food itself was phenomenal. My table had a variety from steak to scallops to fish. All dishes were cooked perfectly.

Finally, we sit outside on patio during the evening. As soon as the air got a chill, out waitress was right there to turn on the outdoor heater and place it next to the ladies.

As you can tell, I can’t say enough good things about this place.

WOW!!! My husband and I arrived early for lunch (11:15am and the open at 11:30am) and they very kindly took our name and asked for us to wait a few moments to be sat. We were then brought to the most beautiful table in the very corner of the patio - AWESOME view! Our server was phenomenal and the food was on point. I very rarely, if ever, take pictures of my food, but i did here!! This was the best food, view, ambiance and service we had the entire time on the island and possibly the best lunch ever. I recommend this place hands down over anywhere else and cant wait to visit again!

What a wonderful dining experience for our anniversary. Our hotel on the island made our reservation easily for 8 o'clock dinner. It was not over crowded or loud. The restaurant is on the lake offering indoor or patio seating with a beautiful view and landscaping. For evening dining I would recommend a dress for ladies and slacks/button down for the men. Piano music was lovely not too loud. Fresh linens were nice. The staff were friendly. Our waiter was friendly and very professional making the dining experience even more enjoyable. He paid attention to every detail, poured our drinks and was very polite. Our pasta shrimp dinners were melt in your mouth full of flavor. The sundae and cream puff desserts were perfect. All the food was made with high quality ingredients. The prices were reasonable for fine dining experience. Worth every penny. I highly recommend! We will be back!