Painted Marlin Grille

Great seafood and view of the bay.

High quality food that is not your boring old seafood Sysco tasting restaurant. We got peel n eat shrimp that were fresh and delicious. The crab cakes were good but not the best I’ve ever had. The mussels and shrimp on angel hair pasta was delicious! Plenty for 2 of us to share.
Drinks are strong here! Wonderful place to eat and enjoy the bay.

We saw the reviews and the crowd this place had. After we waited for 1.5hrs we were seated. Staff was friendly and attentive, including the MOD who took great care. The apps were very good and pictured attached. The drinks were very weak and not the best tasting. If your on the water you should be making the best mojito and margaritas. The fish tacos lacked flavor for sure. Over all great place to check out.

Ordered the shrimp & mussels capellini with the top shelf margarita & house salad. The margarita was the BEST ONE on the island! Refreshing! The house salad used the good lettuce & large tomatoes. The shrimp & mussels were delicious. The pasta lacked a bit of flavor. But overall very happy with the customer service & drinks we got. It’s a nice & relaxing view/ atmosphere

The service was great! Ted made us laugh and feel beyond welcomed! He shared with us their go to options and recommendations, and asked what we liked. When we asked to be surprised as we were celebrating our anniversary, he brought out some delicious options. Everything was cooked well and seasoned perfectly. The view is the extreme bonus! If you haven't gone, it's a must try.

We came to the island as 4 adults who never been here. We loved this place, ate here multiple times in our weeks stay. The atmosphere was awesome, the Sunsets beautiful. The staff was terrific! We all enjoyed our meals every night. The shrimp cocktail was yummy & although there was 5 large shrimp hanging there is 5-6 more chopped in the sauce. The large is big enough for a meal for one. We had the Red Fish, Maui Maui, shrimp (blackened & fried) , the Raspberry Key lime Pie was yummy. It’s not the best place I ever eaten but the best on the island.