Made in New York Pizza

4.5 stars

Made in New York Pizza makes an enjoyable classic New York slice of pizza. the interior has a cool modern vibe with touches of NYC style. there are a couple of standing tables and a couple on the sidewalk as well—there’s also a covered outside shed with seats. definitely a spot that has you covered when you need a quick-bite meal, a pie to go, or late-night calories.

got a plain cheese slice on a warm summer night—and it did not disappoint. melty stretchy mozzarella cheese on a nice layer of flavorful tangy sauce, on a thin crust with a great balance of crispness and chew. thought the slice really was tasty bc the simple flavors really came cleanly from the cheese to the sauce to crust. the slices feel kinda pricy— a plain slice is $3.80 + tip. however the ingredients are likely high quality so you get what you pay for…very good pizza.

staff are quick and friendly enough

Worth trying if you’re looking for a quick bite while on a walk in WV. More solid than expected, and they have GF DF options!

It’s owned by the White Horse Tavern owners.

Amazing Pizza. High quality ingredients. Great in house atmosphere. From the floors to the art on walls, this place screams New York City vibes.

Love the new pizza place in the west village.

The garlic knots were $4 for 3 knots. 😐
The plain was $3.50 and very good.

Definitely recommend and I'll be back 😎.

Also, cool art on the inside.