Address: 258 E 14th St, Elmira Heights, NY 14903, USA
“Best Breakfast Sandwich in all of Elmira and the home of Big Nerd Coffee! Often they use local ingredients as well from The Golden Calf! Love seeing business owners help other business owners! I can't say enough about how this is a gem in Elmira !”
Address: 1360 Lakeland Ave, Bohemia, NY 11716, USA
“Hands down the best catering experience I ever had!! It was a last minute party my family asked me to host since cousins from out West unexpectedly visited ( that’s another story 🥴). This was on a Friday and we were looking to throw a party on Saturday afternoon. I called The Gourmet Bagel Co and explained my situation. The owners were fantastic and extremely accommodating given the short notice. They went through the menu and made suggestions for the amount of people I had. The next day they delivered amazing platters of wraps, salads and mini sandwiches that my family loved. The food was simply amazing! They use really good ingredients and didn’t cut any corners on the presentation. My wife was thrilled and insists we only cater from them in the future. Thanks for helping on such short notice and delivering an amazing meal for an unexpected event”
Address: 2310 Nesconset Hwy, Stony Brook, NY 11790, USA
“It’s a comprehensive deli experience with nice seating and opens early! The iced coffee is great!”
Address: 2184 Nesconset Hwy, Stony Brook, NY 11790, USA
“This is more than a bagel store…it’s a very nice, large, and clean eatery…similar to a Panera. The menu is quite extensive with home made salads and cream cheeses. Their unique sandwiches are packed with meats and cheeses. But maybe most of all, this bagel store is family owned and pay attention to details and they treat their customers as if we were part of that family too. I highly recommend them for catering as well. Beautifully made platters and heroes were delivered for a party I was having and my guests enjoyed every bite!”
Address: 3103 Rte 9W, Saugerties, NY 12477, USA
“The best bagel I have eaten in years. Enormous size, perfectly cooked egg, nice soft warm bagel. Grabbed a quick lunch with a friend and the staff was extremely friendly. The Interior of the shop was lovely with wood paneling everywhere. I would drive three hours again just for the bagel even if I didn't have anything to do in the area. Five stars for sure.”
Address: 731 Middle Country Rd, St James, NY 11780, USA
“Their bagels and cream cheeses are delicious! The service was good, too.”
Address: 248 Smithtown Blvd #9, Nesconset, NY 11767, USA
“Picked up catering for a brunch party and everything was so delicious. Portions were very generous and I had yummy leftovers for days. Very thankful I found this establishment. Keep up the good work!”
Address: 2121 Ulster Ave, Lake Katrine, NY 12449, USA
“I so wanted to give a 5 star rating. Great staff. Clean building. Great food. But that driveway and parking area is treacherous. Other than that it's a great place to grab a bite. And would recommend when you drive in pay attention to holes in roadway and parking lot”
Address: 1198 Middle Country Rd, Selden, NY 11784, USA
“They have all different kinds of egg, ham, sausage based breakfast options starting from $4.30 to $9.50 in 2022. Bagel only line is quick and dedicated. There's space for eating in too. People are friendly. Mostly white people but I saw a black dude ordering breakfast there too. It's a nice cozy, friendly morning bagel 🥯 shop.”
Address: 211 W 2nd St, Elmira, NY 14901, USA
“I wished they'd have plate that had room for all breakfast items instead of bringing multiple plates. This server didn't come check whether we needed a coffee refill? Get some Sirius XM station in there with a jazz station. It would liven up the place. Still needs some jazz or some TVs playing the news in tye background.”
Address: 117 Terry Rd, Smithtown, NY 11787, USA
“Went in here for the first time today after passing it by 1000 times. Even my son said, "Wow Mom. What a clean and friendly bagel shop this is." He couldn't have said it better. The shop is clean, staff is super friendly, and the bagels are huge! Definitely making this our regular weekend stop.”
Address: 15-5 Bennetts Rd, Setauket- East Setauket, NY 11733, USA
“Pleasant enough staff, decent enough bagels. Nothing particularly outstanding. It's your normal neighborhood bagel spot, you know?”
Address: 496 Albany Ave, Kingston, NY 12401, USA
“First thing to note...they are cash only! Secondly, I'll definitely be going again. A friend of mine that lives over an hour away from Kingston drives to get 2 dozen bagels here every couple months. She wraps and freezes them which is what I intended to do. For her to drive over an hour to get bagels, I figured it was a place I had to check out. First time I've ever seen a pumpernickel raisin product. So those were first ones I had added to the bag. Gotta say, I'm sadly disappointed in the flavor. I love pumpernickel but these barely have any pumpernickel flavor and not many raisins. However...the size of these bagels is crazy awesome. They are also so fresh tasting, chewy, and then super soft on the inside. I can see why they are so popular and well liked. I have since tried a plain bagel and a cinnamon raisin. Cinnamon raisin lacking in cinnamon flavor and raisins. I know their sandwiches are very popular and plan on trying one next time I go. I still have other flavors to try like the Garlic, Everything, Salt, and regular pumpernickel. I really wanted to try their blueberry but they were out of them. While some flavors might be lacking in taste, I still have to give 4 stars just based on the size, texture, chewy/softness, freshness and price. Under $12 for a dozen fresh, homemade bagels!!! That's fabulous. I went around 12:30 on a Saturday afternoon and it wasn't incredibly busy. Busy but not overwhelming. If I were ordering a sandwich or going during the morning, I suspect the wait would have been longer. But just grabbing a couple dozen bagels was quick and easy. One last thing...if you are vegan they unfortunately do not have any bagels that are vegan friendly. I messaged them and asked.”
Address: Selden, NY 11727, USA
“Great bagels, rolls, and breakfast sandwiches. Always fresh. Never disappointed. The line could be long in the morning though.”
Address: 555 Montauk Hwy, Bay Shore, NY 11706, USA
“An institution. I’ve been coming here since I was a child, every Easter especially. I had a very nice tuna pumpernickel bagel today. Come before 2:30 or call in for the hot food. Wonder if they’ll bring back text to order!”
Address: 25 Gibbs Rd, Coram, NY 11727, USA
“Best bagels around by far. Stays soft for a week and sandwich prices are the lowest around.”
Address: 658 Long Island Motor Parkway #5, Hauppauge, NY 11788, USA
“Good service... Good food.”
Address: 174 NY-199, Red Hook, NY 12571, USA
“Best bagels around and great customer service. Shop local.”
Address: 9 Glenwood Ave, Binghamton, NY 13905, USA
“Everything from savory to sweet is delicious they just need to put more lox on my sandwich”
Address: 1927 Curry Rd, Schenectady, NY 12303, USA
“I love this place. Great tasting bagels and soups. Really nice staff. Their lox and bagel with 3 cheese Asiago bagel is to die for.”
Address: 100 Pantigo Pl, East Hampton, NY 11937, USA
“Love this place - my favorite Goldbergs location!! Staff are fantastic, service is great, and prices are solid! If you are just ordering plain bagels/spreads - you can order at the counter to the right and avoid some of the line. Highly recommend their lox cream cheese!”
Address: 57 Kirk Ave, Montauk, NY 11954, USA
“Great breakfast and lunch place. My go-to when in Montauk 👍🏼👍🏼”
Address: 36 Veterans Memorial Hwy, Commack, NY 11725, USA
“Nice place. Food is average. The biggest complaint i have is its very expensive. They charged me 1.50 each to add lettuce and tomato to my sandwich. I could see maybe .50. My wife and I ordered a salad and chicken sandwich which came to 35 bucks. Very pricey for deli type food. Again, no complaints about the food as it was ok but I will be going to other local places in the future.”
Address: 260 Commack Rd, Commack, NY 11725, USA
“Not a great selection of cold cuts... just your basics pretty much since it's a small deli. If you want any "specialty" cold cuts I recommend going elsewhere. However, they're getting 4 stars since the sandwiches were solid - not skimpy in the least. Salads were also fresh. A good place for a quick sandwich or a bagel and they have breakfast sandwiches as well.”
Address: 4 Vanderbilt Motor Pkwy, Commack, NY 11725, USA
“Very good. The ice tea isn't super sweet which I liked my husband didn't love that. The Bacon Egg and cheese seemed it would be perfect but it was covered in pepper never had that much applied before the bread was black. We will try again since it was raved about as best bagels in town and we will close.”
Address: 2444, 290 Larkfield Rd, East Northport, NY 11731, USA
“A GREAT PLACE TO GO FOR FAST SERVICE AN GREAT FOOD NICE CLEAN AN FRIENDLY PEOPLE LOVE THEM .ALWAYS GREAT..”
Address: 25 N Pearl St, Albany, NY 12207, USA
“Arguably the best donuts in Albany and surrounding areas. My favorite is the sprinkle covered donuts. Love! And they have awesome coffee beverages.”
Address: 126 N Carll Ave, Babylon, NY 11702, USA
“Line was long but moved quickly. Was a little pricey...$30 for 2 breakfast sandwiches, a hero and a gatorade. My son loved the hero”
Address: 1976 Deer Pk Ave, Deer Park, NY 11729, USA
“My go to bagel spot! I’ve tried many and coming from queens I still loved this place for bagels! I’ve tried Wally’s bagels and still come to this place. I’m not a huge fan of their pastries, they’re ok, and other menu items but they do bagels well! Not only is the variety insane for bagels, but the cream cheeses as well! Manager is super helpful and kind as well as the rest of the staff. Def depends on who’s making my bagel, but for the most part it comes out great.”